Review: Gardens of the Moon

Title: Gardens of the Moon
Author: Steven Erikson
Pages: 666
Series: Malazan Book of the Fallen #1
Release: April 1, 1999


And so begins my journey into Malazan. Is it for me? We shall see… this first book was a mixed bag. I appreciated its scope and complexity, but sometimes felt lost with how many similar male characters there were to keep track of. The podcasts and reading guides were a tremendous help, but felt like homework at times.

I’ve read a lot of epic fantasy and this feels a cut above the rest. The fact that I’ve just scratched the surface of the Malazan world is very exciting. And if this is the low water mark for the series, I’m excited to see what’s to come.

★★★½

Review: The Mad Ship

les-aventuriers-de-la-mer,-tome-5---prisons-d-eau-et-de-bois-369293-250-400Title: The Mad Ship (1999)
Author: Robin Hobb
Pages: 906
Series: Liveship Traders #2, Realms of the Elderlings #5 (Series Tracker)

The Mad Ship continues the conquests of those we met in Ship of Magic, while adding a few new character POVs to the fold. As paths cross and fates entwine, many single POVs pair together and the narration becomes more cohesive. Nevertheless, this is much less a complete tale as it is a continuation from book #1 — and with no definitive ending, I suspect book #3 will follow the same path. In many ways this trilogy is one loooong book, sliced into three parts.  

I have been burning through Robin Hobb’s work pretty steadily over the last few months, and I hit a wall with this book. As a reader, I seek fresh new journeys, but this ongoing saga progresses at such a slow pace that it was tough to stay as consistently enthralled as I was at the outset. Luckily, the quality of Hobb’s writing remains top notch and the story grabbed me back as the ending approached.

With such a heavy emphasis on character development, it’s easy to overlook how well Hobb does story revelations. She plants seeds for overarching mysteries that are very hard to solve as the reader, but when the answers are revealed they are surprising, satisfying, and they have ramifications for the overall Realms of the Elderlings world that keep me excited for each subsequent book.

★★★¾ out of 5